LETTER XXI
Friday, December 28, 1849
I resume my inquiry whether stimulating drinks are
necessary for the performance of severe labour.
It may be recollected that in
Letter XIX I published the statement of a coal-backer, who declared that it was
an absolute necessity of that kind of labour that the men engaged in backing
coals from the hold of a ship should, though earning only £1 per week, spend at
least 12s. weekly in beer and spirits to stimulate them for the work. This sum,
the man assured me, was a moderate allowance, for 15s. was the amount ordinarily
expended by the men in drink every week. Hence it followed, that if this
quantity of drink was a necessity of the calling, the men pursuing the
severest labour of all-doing work that cripples the strongest in from twelve to
twenty years- were the worst paid of all labourers, their actual clear gains
being only from 5s. to 8s. per week. This struck me as being so terrible
a state of things, that I could hardly believe it to be true, though I was
assured by several coal-whippers, who were present on the occasion, that the
coal-backer who had made the statement had in no way exaggerated his account of
the sufferings of his fellow-workmen. I determined, nevertheless, upon inquiring
into the question myself, and ascertaining, by the testimony and experience of
different classes of individuals engaged in this, the greatest labour, perhaps,
performed by any men, whether drink was really a necessity or luxury to the
working man.
Accordingly I called a meeting of the coal-whippers, that I
might take their opinion on the subject, when I found that out of eighty
individuals only four were satisfied that fermented liquors could be dispensed
with by the labouring classes. I was, however, still far from satisfied upon the
subject, and I determined, as the question is one of the greatest importance to
the working men - being more intimately connected with their welfare, physical,
intellectual, and moral than any other - to give the subject my most patient and
unbiased consideration. I was anxious, without advocating any opinion upon the
subject, to collect the sentiments of the coal-labourers themselves; and in
order that I might do so as impartially as possible, I resolved upon
seeing-first, such men as were convinced that stimulating liquors were necessary
to the labouring man in the performance of his work - 2nd. such men as once
thought differently, and, indeed, had once taken the pledge to abstain from the
use of all fermented liquors, but had been induced to violate their vow in
consequence of injury to their health - and 3rd. such men as had taken the
pledge and kept it without any serious injury to their constitutions. To carry
the subject out with the fulness and impartiality that its importance seemed to
me to demand, I further determined to prosecute the inquiry among both classes
of coal-labourers--the coal-whippers, and coal-backers as well. The result of
these investigations I shall now subjoin. Let me, however, in the first place
lay before the reader the following
COMPARATIVE TABLE OF DRUNKENNESS OF THE DIFFERENT TRADES IN LONDON.
ABOVE THE AVERAGE.
Buttonmakers,
1 individual in every 7.2
Toolmakers 10.1
Surveyors 11.8
Papermakers and stainers 12.1
Brass founders 12.4
Goldbeaters 14.5
Millers 16.6
French polishers 17.3
Cutlers 18.2
Corkcutters 19.7
Musicians 22.0
Opticians 22.3
Bricklayers 22.6
Labourers 22.8
General and marine store dealers 23.2
Brushmakers 24.4
Fishmongers 28.2
Coach and cabmen 28.7
Glovers 29.4
Smiths 29.5
Sweeps 32.2
Hairdressers 42.3
Tailors 43.7
Tinkers and tinmen 45.7
Saddlers 49.3
Masons 49.6
Glassmakers, &c 50.5
Curriers 50.6
Printers, 1 individual in every 52.4
Hatters and trimmers 53.1
Carpenters 53.8
Ironmongers 56.0
Dyers 56.7
Sawyers 58.4
Turners 59.3
Engineers 59.7
Butchers 63.7
Laundresses 63.8
Painters 66.1
Brokers 67.7
Medical men 68.0
Brewers 70.2
Clerks 73.4
Shopkeepers 77.1
Shoemakers 78.0
Coachmakers 78.8
Milliners 81.4
Bakers 82.0
Pawnbrokers 84.7
Gardeners 97.6
Weavers 99.3
Drapers 102.3
Tobacconists 103.4
Jewellers 104.5
Artists 106.3
Publicans 108.0
Average 113.8
BELOW THE AVERAGE
Carvers
and Gilders 125.2
Artificial Flowermakers 128.1
Bookbinders 128.1
Greengrocers 157.4
Watchmakers 204.2
Grocers 226.6
Clockmakers 286.0
Parish Officers 373.0
Clergymen 417.0
Servants 585.7
The above calculations have been made from the official returns of the
Metropolitan Police for 1848. The causes of the different degrees of
intemperance here exhibited I leave to others to discover.
After the meeting of coal-whippers,
described in my last letter, I requested some of the men who had expressed the
various opinions respecting the necessity for drinking some kind of fermented
liquor during their work, to meet me, so that I might take down their sentiments
on the subject more fully. First of all came two of the most intelligent, who
believed malt liquor to be necessary for the performance of their labour. One
was a basket-man, or fireman, and the other an "up-and-down" man, or
whipper; the first doing the lighter, and the second the heavier kind of work.
The basket - man-who, I afterwards discovered, was a good Greek and Latin
scholar-said, "If I have anything like a heavy day's work to do, I consider
three pints of porter a day necessary. We are not like other labouring men,
having an hour to dinner. Often, to save time, we take only ten minutes to our
meals. One thing I wish to remark is, that what renders it necessary to have the
three pints of beer, in winter, and two pots in summer is the coal-dust arising
from the work, which occasions great thirst. In the summer time the basket-man
is on the plank all day, and continually exposed to the sun, and in winter to
the inclemency of the weather. What with the labour and the heat, the
perspiration is excessive. A basket-man with a bad gang of men has no sinecure.
In the summer he can wear neither coat nor waistcoat - very few can bear the hat
on the head, and they wear nightcaps instead. The work is always done in summer
time with only the shirt and trousers on. The basket-man never takes off his
shirt like the whippers. The necessity for drink in the summer does not arise so
much from the extent of the labour as from the irritation of the coal-dust
getting into the throat. There is not so much dust from the coals in the winter
as in the summer, the coals being more damp in wet than in fine weather. It is
merely the thirst that makes the drink requisite, as far as the basket-man is
concerned. Tea would allay the thirst, but there is no opportunity of having
this on board ship. If there were an opportunity of having tea at our work, the
basket-man might manage to do with it as well as with beer. Water I don't fancy,
especially the water of the river- it is very impure; and at the time of the
cholera we were prohibited from drinking it. If we could get pure water I do not
think it would do as well for us, especially in winter time. In winter time it
would be too cold, and too great a contrast to the heat of the blood. It would,
in my opinion, produce stagnation in the circulation. We have had instances of
men dying suddenly through drinking water when in a state of excitement"
(He distinguishes between excitement and perspiration-he calls the basket-man's
labour an exciting one, and the whipper's work a heating one). "The men who
died suddenly were whippers. I never heard of a basket-man dying from drinking
cold water when at his work. I don't think they ever tried the experiment. The
whippers have done so through necessity, not through choice. Tea is a beverage
that I don't fancy, and I conceive it to be equally expensive, so I prefer
porter. When I go off to my work early in the morning I take about a pint of
coffee with me in a bottle, and warm it up on board, at the galley fire, for my
breakfast; that I find quenches my thirst for the time as well as porter. Porter
would be too insipid the first thing in the morning. I never drank coffee
through the day while at my work, so I cannot say what the effect would be. I
drink porter when at my work, not as giving me greater strength to go through my
labour, but merely as a means of quenching my thirst-it being as cheap as any
other drink, with the exception of water, and less trouble to procure. Water I
consider dangerous at our work; but I can't say that it is so from my own
experience. I was in the hospital about seven years ago, and the doctor there
asked me how many pints of beer I was in the habit of drinking per day. This was
before the office was established. I told him, on the lowest calculation, six or
seven-it was the case then under the old system-and he then ordered me two pints
of porter a day, as I was very weak, and he said I wanted a stimulus. I am not
aware that it is the habit of the publicans to adulterate their porter with salt
and water. If such is the case it would without a doubt increase rather than
diminish the thirst. I have often found that the beer sold by some of the
publicans tends more to create than allay thirst. I am confident, if the working
men generally knew that salt and water was invariably mixed with the porter by
the publicans, they would no longer hold to the notion that it could quench
their thirst; but to convince them of that it would almost be necessary that
they should see the publican adulterating the beer with their own eyes. If it
really is the case that beer is adulterated with salt and water, it must be both
injurious and heating to the labouring man. Some of the men, who are in the
habit of drinking porter at their work, very probably attribute the thirst
created by the salt and water in the porter, to the thirst created by the
coal-dust or the work, and continue drinking it from the force of habit. The
habit of drinking is doubtlessly the effect of the old system, when the men were
forced to drink by the publicans who paid them. A most miraculous change and one
unparalleled in history has been produced by altering the old mode of employing
and paying the men. The reformation in the morals and characters of the men is
positively wonderful. The sons are no longer thieves, and the daughters are no
longer prostitutes. Formerly it was a competition who could drink the most; for
he who could do so got the most work. The introduction for a job was invariably
- 'you know Mr. So-and-so, I'm a good drinking man.' Seeing the benefit that has
resulted from the men not drinking so much as formerly, I am of opinion, though
I take my beer every day myself, a great good would ensue if the men would drink
even less than they do now, and eat more. It would be more conducive to their
health and strength. But they have not the same facility of getting food when
over their work, as there is for getting beer. You see they can have credit for
beer when they can't get a morsel of food on trust. There are no floating
butchers or bakers like there are floating publicans or purl-men. If there were,
and men could have trust for bread and meat while at their work on the river, I
am sure they would eat more and drink less, and be all the better for it. It
would be better for themselves and for their families. The great evil of the
drink is, that when a man has a little he often wants more, and doesn't know
where to stop. When he once passes the rubicon, as I call it, he is lost. If it
wasn't for this evil I think a pint or two of porter would make them do their
work better than either tea or water. Our labour is peculiar. The air is always
full of coal- dust, and every nerve and muscle of the body is strained, and
every pore of the body open, so that he requires some drink that will counteract
the cold."
The next two that I saw were men who did the heaviest work -
that is, "up-and-down" men, or coal-whippers, as they are usually
called. They had both of them been teetotallers. One had been so for eight
years, and the other one had tried it for three months. One, who stood at least
six feet and a-half high, and was habited in a long blue great coat that reached
to his heels, and made him look even taller than he was, said, "I was a
strict teetotaller for many years, and I wish I could be so now. All that time I
was a coal-whipper, at the heaviest work, and I have made one of a gang that
have done as many as 180 tons in one day. I drank no fermented liquor the whole
of the time. I had only ginger-beer and milk, and that cost me 1s. 6d. It was in
the summer time. I didn't 'buff it' on that day; that is, I didn't take my shirt
off. I did this work at the Regent's Canal, and there was a little milk shop
close on shore, and I used to run there when I was dry. I had about two quarts
of milk and five bottles of ginger-beer, or about three quarts of fluid
altogether. I found that amount of drink necessary. I perspired very violently -
my shirt was wet through, and my flannels wringing wet with the perspiration
over the work. The rule among us is that we do 28 tons on deck, and 28 tons
filling in the ship's hold. We go on in that way throughout the day. spelling at
every 28 tons. The perspiration in the summer time streams down our foreheads so
rapidly, that it will often get into our eyes before we have time to wipe it
off. This makes the eyes very sore. At night when we get home we cannot bear to
sit with a candle. The perspiration is of a very briny nature, for I often taste
it as it runs down to my lips. We are often so heated over our work that the
perspiration runs into the shoes; and often, from the dust and heat, jumping up
and down, and the feet being galled with the small dust, I have had my shoes
full of blood. The thirst produced by our work is very excessive. It is
completely as if you had a fever upon you. The dust gets into the throat, and
very nearly suffocates you. You can scrape the coal-dust off the tongue with the
teeth; and do what you will, it is impossible to get the least spittle into the
mouth. I have known the coal-dust to be that thick in a ship's hold, that 1 have
been unable to see my mate, though he was only two feet from me. Your legs
totter under you. Both before and after I was a teetotaller, I was one of the
strongest men in the business. I was able to carry seven hundredweight on my
back for fifty yards, and I could lift nine half-hundreds with my right arm.
After finishing my day's work I was like a child with weakness. When we have
done 14, or 28 tons, we generally stop for a drop of drink, and then I have
found that anything that would wet my mouth would revive me. Cold tea, milk, or
ginger-beer, were refreshing, but not so much as a pint of porter. Cold water
would give a pain in the inside, so that a man would have to lie down and be
taken ashore, and perhaps give up work altogether. Many a man has been taken to
the hospital merely through drinking cold water over his work. They have
complained of a weight and coldness in the chest. They say it has chilled the
fat of the heart. I can positively state," continued the man, "that
during the whole of eight years I took no fermented drink. My usual drink was
cold tea, milk, ginger-beer, or coffee- whichever I could catch. The ginger-beer
was more lively than the milk, but I believe I could do more work upon the milk.
Tea I found much better than coffee. Cold tea was very refreshing; but if I
didn't take it with me in a bottle, it wasn't to be had. I used to take a quart
of cold tea with me in a bottle, and make that do for me all day, as well as I
could. The ginger-beer was the most expensive, and would cost me is., or more
than that, if 1 could get it. The milk would cost me 6d. or 8d. For tea and
coffee the expense would be about 2d. the day. But often I have done the whole
day's work without any drink, because I would not touch beer, and then I was
more fit to be carried home than walk. I have known many men scarcely able to
crawl up the ladder out of the hold, they were so fatigued. For myself, being a
very strong man, I was never so reduced, thank God. But often when I've got home
I've been obliged to drink three pints of milk at a stretch before 1 could touch
a bit of victuals. As near as I can guess, it used to cost me when at work 1s. a
day for milk, ginger-beer, and other teetotal drinks. When I was not at work my
drink used to cost me little or nothing. For eight years I stuck to the pledge,
but I found myself failing in strength and health; I found that I couldn't go
through a day's work as clever as I used before I left off drink, and when first
I was a teetotaller. I found myself failing in every inch of my carcase, my
limbs, my body, and all. Of my own free will I gave it up. I did not do so in a
fit of passion, but deliberately, because I was fully satisfied that it was
injuring my health. Shortly after I had taken the pledge I found I could have
more meat than I used to have before, and I found that I neither got strong nor
weak upon it. After about five years my appetite began to fail, and then I found
my strength leaving me; so I made up my mind to alter the system. When I
returned to beer, I found myself getting better in health and stronger daily.
Before I was a teetotaller I used to drink heavy, but after teetotalism I was a
temperate man. I am sure it is necessary for a hard-working man that he should
drink beer. lie can't do his work so well without it as he can with it, in
moderation. If he goes beyond his allowance he is better without any. I have
taken to drinking beer again within the last twelve months. As long as a man
does not go beyond his allowance in beer, his drink will cost him quite as much
when he is a teetotaller as it will when he has not taken the pledge. The
difference between the teetotal and fermented drinks I find to be this-when I
drank milk it didn't make me any livelier; it quenched my thirst, but did not
give me any strength. But when I drink a pint or a quart of beer, it does me so
much good after a day's labour, that after drinking it I could get up and go to
my work again. This feeling would continue for a considerable time. Indeed, I
think the beer is much better for a hard-working man, than any unfermented
drink. I defy any man in England to contradict me in what I say, and that is, 'A
man who takes his reasonable quantity of beer, and a fair share of food, is much
better with it than without.' "
Another man, who had been a teetotaller for three months at
one time, and seven years at another, was convinced that it was impossible for a
hard-working man to do his work as well without beer as with. He had tried it
twice, and he spoke from his own experience, and would say that a little - that
is, two pints or three for a very hard day's labour - would never hurt no man.
Beyond that a man has no right to go; indeed, anything extra only makes him
stupid. Under the old system I used to be obliged to buy rum, and over and over
again I've had to pay 15d. for a half a pint of rum in a ginger-beer bottle, and
have gone into the street and sold it for 6d., and got a steak with the money.
No man can say drink has ruined my constitution, for I've only had two
penny-worth of antibilious pills in twenty-five years; and I will say a little
beer does a man more good than harm, and too much does a man more harm than
good.
The next two "whippers" that I saw were both
teetotallers. One had taken the pledge eight months ago and the other four
years, and they had both kept it strictly. One had been cellarman at a
public-house; and he said, "I neither take spruce, nor any of the cordials.
Water is my beverage at dinner." The other had been an inveterate drunkard.
The cellarman is now a basket-man, and the other an up-and-down man, or whipper,
in the same gang. The basket-man said, "I can say this from my own
experience, that it is not necessary for a working man, doing the very hardest
labour, to drink fermented liquors. I was an up-and-down man for two years
without tasting a drop of beer or spirits. I have helped to whip 189 tons of
coal in one day without any, and that in the heat of summer. What I had with me
was a bottle of cocoa, and I took with that plenty of steak, potatoes, and
bread. If the men was to take more meat, and less beer, they would do much
better. It's a delusion to think beer necessary. Often the men who say the beer
is necessary will deliver a ship, aye, and not half a dozen half-pints be drank
aboard. The injury is done ashore. The former custom of our work - the
compulsory system of drinking that we was under - has so embedded the idea of
drink in the men, that they think it is actually necessary. It's not the least
to be wondered at that there's so many drunkards among them. I don't think we
shall ever be able to undo the habit of drinking among the whippers in this
generation. As far as I am concerned. since I have been a teetotaller, I have
enjoyed a more regular state of health than I used before. Now that I am a
basket-man I drink only water with my dinner, and during my work I take nothing.
I have got a ship "in hands," going to work on Monday morning. I shall
have to run backwards and forwards on a one-and-twenty foot plank, and deliver
300 tons of coals, and I shall do that upon water. That man," pointing to
the teetotaller who accompanied him, "will be in it, and he'll have to help
to pull the coals twenty foot above the deck, and he'll do it all upon water.
When I was a coal-whipper myself I used to drink cocoa. I took it cold with me
of a morning and warmed it aboard. They prophesied it would kill me in a week,
but I know it's done me every good in life. I have drunk water when I was a
working up-and-down, and when I was in the highest perspiration, and never found
it injure me. It allays the thirst more than anything. If it didn't allay the
thirst, I should want to drink often; but if I take a drink of water from the
cask, I find my thirst immediately quenched. Many of the men who drink beer will
take a drink of water afterwards, because the beer increases their thirst and
heats them; that I believe is principally from the salt-water in it; in fact, it
stands to reason that, if beer is half brine, it can't quench thirst. Ah! it's
shocking stuff the purlmen make up for them on the river. When I was drinking
beer at my employment I used seldom to exceed three pints of beer a day - that
is what I took on board. What I had on shore of course was not to help me to do
my labour. I know the beer used to inflame my thirst, because I've had to drink
water after it over and over again. I never made a habit of drinking - not since
the establishment of the office. Previous to that, of course I was compelled to
drink. I've got "jolly" now and then; but I never made a habit of it.
It used to cost me about 2s. or 2s. 6d. a week on the average for drink at the
uttermost, because I couldn't afford more. Since I've taken the pledge I'm sure
it hasn't cost me 6d. a week. A teetotaller feels less thirst than any other
man. I don't know what natural thirst is, except I've been eating salt
provisions. I belong to a total abstinence society, and there are about a dozen
coal-whippers, and about the same number of coal-backers, members of it. Some
have been total abstainers for twelve years, and are living witnesses that
fermented drinks are not necessary for working men. There are about 200 to 250
coal-whippers, I have been given to understand, who are teetotallers. Those
coal-whippers who have been total abstainers for twelve years are not weaker or
worse in health for the want of beer." [This statement was denied by a
person present; but a gentleman, who was intimately acquainted with the whole
body, mentioned the names of several men who had been-some ten years, and some
upwards of twelve years-strict adherents to the principle of teetotalism.]
"The great quantity of drinking is carried on ashore. I should say the men
generally drink twice as much ashore as they do afloat. Those who drink beer are
always thirsty. Through drinking over their work, aboard, a thirst is created,
which they set to drinking when ashore to allay; and after a hard day's labour a
very little overcomes a man. One or two pots of beer, and the man is loth to
stir. He is tired, and the drink, instead of refreshing him, makes him sleepy
and heavy. The next morning after drinking he is thirstier still, and then he
goes to work drinking again. The perspiration will start out of him in large
drops like peas; you will see it stream down his face and his hands with the
coal-dust sticking to them just like as if he had a pair of silk gloves on him.
It's a common saying with us about such a man that he's got the gloves on. The
drunkards always perspire the most over their work. The prejudice existing among
the men in favour of drink is such that they believe they would die if they went
without it. I am quite astonished to see such an improvement in them as there
is; and I do think that if the clergymen of the neighbourhood did their
duty and exerted themselves, the people would be better still. At one time there
was as many as 500 coal-whippers total abstainers, and the men were much better
clothed, and the homes and appearance of the whippers were much more decent.
What I should do if I drunk I don't know. I got £1 for clearing a ship last
week, and I shan't get any more till Monday night, and I have six children and a
wife to keep out of that. For this last fortnight I have only made 10s. a week,
so I am sure I couldn't even afford is. a week for drink without robbing my
family."
The second teetotaller, who had been an inveterate drunkard
in his time, stated as follows:-Like the rest of the coal-whippers, he thought
once that he could not do his work without beer. He used to drink as much as he
could get. He averaged two pots at his work, and when he came on shore he would
have two pots more. He had been a coal-whipper for upwards of twenty years, and
for nineteen years and three months of that time he was a hard drinker - a
regular stiff one, said he. "I not only used," he added, "to get
drunk myself, but I taught my children to do so. I have got sons as big as
myself, coal-backers, and total abstainers. Often I have gone home of a Sunday
morning drunk myself, and found two of my sons drunk. They'd be unable to sit at
the table. They were about fourteen then, and when they went out with me I used
to teach them to take their little drops of neat rum or gin. I have seen the
youngest mop up' his half-quartern as well as I did. Then I was always thirsty;
and when I got up of a morning I used to go stalking round to the first
public-house that was open. to see if I could get a pint or a quartern. My mouth
was dry and parched as if I had got a burning fever. If I had no work that day.
I used to sit in a public-house, and spend all the money I'd got. If I had no
money, I would go home and raise it somehow. I would ask the old woman to give
me the price of a pint, or perhaps the young on's were at work, and I was pretty
safe to meet them coming home. Talk about going out of a Sunday! I was ashamed
to be seen out. My clothes were ragged, and my shoes would take the water in at
one end and let it out again at the other. I keep my old rags at home to remind
me of what I was, I call them the regimentals of the guzzileers. I pawned
everything I could get at. For ten or twelve years I used a beer-shop regularly.
That was my house of call. Now my home is very happy. All my children are
teetotallers. My sons are as big as myself, and they are at work, carrying 1¾
cwt. to 2 cwt. up a Jacob's ladder thirty-three steps high. They do this all day
long, and have been doing so for the last seven days. They drink nothing but
water or cold tea, and say they find themselves the better able to do their
work. Coal- backing is about the hardest labour a man can perform. For myself,
too, I find I am quite as able to do my work without intoxicating drinks as I
was with them. There's my basketman," said he, pointing to the other
teetotaller, "and he can tell you whether what I say is true or not. I have
helped to whip 147 tons of coal in the heat of summer. The other men were
calling for beer every time they could see or hear a purl-man, but I took
nothing. I don't think I perspired so much as they did. When I was in the
drinking custom I have known the perspiration run down my legs and arms as if
I'd been in a hot bath. Since I've taken the pledge I scarcely perspire at all.
I'll work against any man that takes beer, provided I have a good teetotal
pill-that is, a good pound of steak with plenty of gravy in it. That's the stuff
to work upon. That's what the working man wants - plenty of it, and less beer,
and he'd beat a horse any day. I am satisfied that the working man can never be
raised above his present position until he can give over drinking. That is the
reason why I'm sticking to the pledge, that I may be a living example to my
class that they can and may work without beer. It has made my home happy, and I
want it to make every other working man's as comfortable. I tried the principle
of teetotalism first on board a steamboat. I was stoker, and we burnt
twenty-seven cwt. of coals every hour we were at sea-that's very nearly a ton
and a half per hour. There, with the heat of the fire, we felt the effects of
drinking strong brandy. Brandy was the only fermented drink we were allowed.
After a time I tried what other stimulants we could use. The heat in the hold,
especially before the fires, was awful. There were nine stokers and four coal
trimmers. We found the brandy that we drank in the day made us ill-our heads
ached when we got up in the morning; so four of us agreed to try oatmeal and
water as our drink, and we found that suited us better than intoxicating liquor.
I myself got as fat as a bull upon it. It was recommended to me by a doctor in
Falmouth, and we all of us tried it eight or nine voyages. Some time after I
left the company I went to strong drink again, and continued at it till the
first of May last; and then my children's love of drink got so dreadful that I
got to hate myself as being the cause of it. But I couldn't give up the
drinking. Two of my mates, however, urged me on to try. On the 1st of May I
signed the pledge. I prayed to God on the night I went to give me strength to
keep it, and never since have I felt the least inclination to return. When I had
left off a fortnight I found myself a great deal better; all the cramps that I
had been loaded with when I was drinking left me. Now I am happy and comfortable
at home. My wife's about one of the best women in the world. She bore with me in
all my troubles, and now she glories in my redemption. My children love me, and
we club all our earnings together, and can always on a Sunday manage a joint of
sixteen or seventeen pounds. My wife, now that we are teetotallers, need do no
work; and in conclusion, I must say, that I have much cause to bless the Lord
that ever I signed the teetotal pledge."
"After I leave my work," added the teetotaller,
"I find the best thing I can have to refresh me is a good wash of my face
and shoulders in cold water. This is twice as enlivening as ever I found beer.
Once a fortnight I go over to Goulston-square, Whitechapel, and have a warm
bath. This is one of the finest things that ever was invented for the working
man. Any persons that use them don't want beer. I invited a coal-whipper man to
come with me once. 'How much does it cost?' he asked. I told him 1d. Well,' he
said, 'I'd sooner have half a pint of beer. I haven't washed my body for these
22 years, and don't see why I should begin to have anything to do with these
new-fangled notions at my time of life.' I will say that a good wash is better
for the working man than the best drink."
The man ultimately made a particular request that his
statement might conclude with a verse that he had chosen from the Temperance
Melodies:-
"And now we love the social cheer
Of the bright winter eve;
We have no cause for sigh or tear-
We have no cause to grieve.
"Our wives are clad, our children fed;
We boast, where'er we go,
Twas all because we signed the pledge
A long time ago."
At the close of my interview with these men I received from
them an invitation to visit them at their own houses whenever I should think
fit. It was clearly their desire that I should see the comforts and domestic
arrangements of their homes. Accordingly, on the morrow, choosing an hour when
there could have been no preparation, I called at the lodgings of the first. I
found the whole family assembled in the back kitchen, that served them for a
parlour. As I entered the room the mother was busy at work, washing and dressing
her children for the day. There stood six little things - so young that they
seemed to be all about the same height - with their faces shining with the soap
and water, and their cheeks burning red with the friction of the towel. They
were all laughing and playing about the mother, who, with comb and brush in
hand, found it no easy matter to get them to stand still whilst she made
"the parting." First of all, the man asked me to step upstairs, and
see the sleeping-room. I was much struck with the scrupulous cleanliness of the
apartment. The blind was as white as snow, half rolled up, and fastened with a
pin. The floor was covered with patches of different coloured carpet, showing
that they had been bought from time to time, and telling how difficult it had
been to obtain the luxury. In one corner was a cupboard, with the door taken
off, the better to show all the tumblers, teacups, and coloured glass mugs,
that, with two decanters well covered with painted flowers, were kept more for
ornament than use. On the chimney-piece was a row of shells, china shepherdesses
and lambs, and a stuffed pet canary in a glass case for a centre ornament.
Against the wall, surrounded by other pictures, hung a half-crown water-colour
drawing of the wife with a child on her knee, matched on the other side by the
husband's likeness, cut out in black paper. Pictures of bright coloured ducks,
and a print of Father Moore, the teetotaller, completed the collection.
"You see," said the man, "we manages pretty
well; but I can assure you we has a hard time of it to do it at all comfortably.
Me and my wife is just as we stands. All our other things are in pawn. If I was
to drink, I don't know what I should do. How others manage is to me a mystery.
This will show you I speak the truth," he added; and going to a secretary
that stood against the wall, he produced a handful of duplicates. There were 17
tickets in all, amounting to £3 0s. 6d., the highest sum borrowed being 10s.
"That'll show you! I don't like my poverty to be known, or I should have
told you of it before. And yet we manages to sleep clean," and he pulled
back the patchwork counterpane and showed me the snow white sheets beneath.
"There's not enough clothes to keep us warm, but at least they're clean.
We're obliged to give as much as we can to the children. Cleanliness is my
wife's hobby, and I let her indulge it. I can assure you last week my wife had
to take the gown off her back to get a shilling with it. My little ones seldom
have a bit of meat from one Sunday to another, and never a bit of butter."
I then descended into the parlour. The children were all
seated on little stools that their father had made for them in his spare
moments, and warming themselves round the fire, their little black shoes resting
on the white hearth. By their regular features, small mouths, large dark eyes,
and fair skins, no one would have taken them for a labouring man's family. In
answer to my questions he said, "The eldest of them (a pretty little half
clad girl, seated in one corner) is ten, the next seven, that one five, that
three, and this (a little thing perched upon a table near the mother) two. I've
got all their ages in the Bible upstairs." I remarked a strange look about
one of the little girls, "Yes, she always suffered with that eye, and down
at the hospital they lately performed an operation on it." An artificial
pupil had been made.
The room was closed in from the passage by a rudely-built
partition. "That I did myself in my leisure," said the man; "it
makes the room snugger. As he saw me looking at the clean rolling-pin and bright
tins hung against the wall," he observed, "That's all my wife's doing.
She has got them together by sometimes going without dinner herself, and laying
out the 2d. or 3d. in things of that sort. That is how she manages. To-day she
has got us a sheep's head and a few turnips for our Sunday's dinner," he
added, taking off the lid off the boiling saucepan. Over the mantelpiece hung a
picture of George IV, surrounded by four other frames. One of them contained
merely three locks of hair. The man, laughing, told me, "Two of them are
locks of myself and my wife, and the light one in the middle belonged to my
wife's brother, who died in India." "That's her doing again," he
added.
After this I paid a visit to the other teetotaller at his
home, and there saw one of his sons. He had six children altogether, and also
supported his wife's mother. If it wasn't for him the poor old thing, who was 75,
and a teetotaller too, must have gone to the workhouse. Three of his six
children lived at home. The other three were out at service. One of the lads at
home was a coal- backer. He was twenty-four years of age, and on an average
could earn 17s. 6d. It was four years since he had taken to backing. He said,
"I am at work at one of the worst wharfs in London. It is called 'The
Slaughterhouse' by the men, because the work is so excessive. The strongest man
can only last twelve years at the work there. After that he is overstrained, and
of no use. I do the hardest work, and carry the coals up from the hold. The
ladder I mount has about 35 steps, and stands very nearly straight on end. Each
time I mount, I carry on my back 238 lb. No man can work at this for more than
five days in the week. I work three days running, then have a day's rest, and
then work two days more. I myself generally do five days' work out of the six. I
never drink any beer, and have not for the last eight months. For three years
and four months I took beer to get over the work. I used to have a pint at
eleven, a pot at dinner, a pint at four o'clock, and double allowance, or a
couple of pots, after work. Very often I had more than double allowance. I
seldom in a day drank less than that; but I have done more. I have drank five
pots in four minutes and a half. So my expenditure for beer was ls. 4d. a day
regularly. Indeed, I used to allow myself three half-crowns to spend in beer a
week, Sundays included. When a coal-worker is in full work, he usually spends
2s. a day, or 12s. a week in beer. The trade calls these men temperate. When
they spend 15s., the trade think they are intemperate. Before I took the
pledge, I scarcely ever went to bed sober after my labour. I was not always
drunk; but I was heavy and stupid with beer. Twice within the time I was a coal-
backer I have been insensibly drunk. I should say three-fourths of the
coal-backers are drunk twice a week. Coal-backing is as heavy a class of labour
as any performed. I don't know any that can beat it. I have been eight months
doing the work, and can solemnly state I have never tasted a drop of fermented
liquor. I have found I could do my work better and brisker than when I drank. I
never feel thirsty over my work now; before I was always dry, and felt as if I
could never drink enough to quench it. Now I never drink from the time I go to
work till the time I have my dinner; then my usual beverage is either cold
coffee or oatmeal and water. From that time I never drink till I take my tea. On
this system I find myself quite as strong as I did with the porter. When I drank
porter, it used to make me go along with a sack a little bit brisker for half an
hour, but after that I was dead and obliged to have some more. There are men at
the wharf who drink beer and spirits that can do six days' labour in the week. I
can't do this myself; I have done as much when I took fermented liquors,
but I only did so by whipping myself up with stimulants. 1 was obliged to drink
every hour a pint of beer to force me along. This was only working for the
publican, for I had less money at the week's end than when I did less work. Now
I can keep longer and more steadily at my work. In a month I would warrant to
back more coals than a drunkard. I think the drunkard can do more for a short
space of time than a teetotaller. I am satisfied the coal- backers, as a class,
would be better off if they left off the drinking. and then masters would not
force them to do so much work after dark as they do now. They always pay at
public-houses. If that system was abandoned, the men would be greatly benefited
by it. Drinking is not a necessity of the labour. All I want when I'm at work is
a bit of coal in the mouth. This not only keeps the mouth cool, but as we go up
the ladder, we very often scrunch our teeth - the work's so hard. The coal keeps
us from biting the tongue- that's one use; the other is, that, by rolling it
along in the mouth, it excites the spittle, and so moistens the mouth. This I
find a great deal better than a pot of porter."
In order to complete my investigations concerning the
necessity of drinking in the coal-whipping trade, I had an interview with some
of the more intelligent of the men who had been principally concerned in the
passing of the act that rescued the class from the "thraldom of the
publican":
"I consider," said one, "that drink is not a
necessity of our labour, but it is a necessity of the system under which we were
formerly working. I have done the hardest work that any labouring man can do,
and drank no fermented liquor. Nor do I consider fermented liquors to be
necessary for the severest labour. This I can say of my own experience, having
been a teetotaller for sixteen months. But if the working man don't have the
drink, he must have good solid food, superior to what he is in the habit of
having. A pot of coffee and a good beef dumpling will get one over the
most severe labour. But if he can't have that he must have the stimulants. A
pint of beer he can always have on credit, but he can't the beef dumpling. If
there is an excuse for any persons drinking, there is for the coalwhippers, for
under the old system they were forced to become habitual drunkards to obtain
work."
I also questioned another of the men who had been a prime
mover in obtaining the act. He assured me that before the "emancipation of
the men the universal belief of the coalwhippers. encouraged by the publicans,
was, that it was impossible for them to work without liquor. In order to do away
with that delusion, the three principal agents in procuring the act became
teetotallers of their own accord, and remained so-one for 16 months, and another
for nine years-in order to prove to their fellow-workmen that drinking over
their labour could be dispensed with, and that they might have "cool brains
to fight through the work they had undertaken."
Another of the more intelligent men, who had been a
teetotaller for three years, told me: "Whilst I was a teetotaller I
performed the hardest labour I ever did before or after, with more ease and
satisfaction than ever I did under the drinking system. It is quite a delusion
to believe that, with proper nutriment, the health declines under habits of
total abstinence."
After this I was anxious to continue my investigations among
the coal porters, and see whether the more intelligent among them were as firmly
convinced as the better class of coal-whippers were that intoxicating drinks
were not necessary for the performance of hard labour. I endeavoured to find one
of each class-pursuing the same plan as I had adopted with the coal-whippers,
viz., I sought first one who was so firmly convinced of the necessity of
drinking fermented liquors during his work that he had never been induced to
abandon them - secondly, I endeavoured to obtain the evidence of one who had
tried the principle of total abstinence, and had found it fail; and, thirdly, I
strove to procure the opinion of those who had been teetotallers for several
years, and who could conscientiously state that no stimulant was necessary for
the performance of their labour. Subjoined is the result of my investigations:-
Concerning the motives and reasons for the great consumption of beer by the
coalporters, I obtained the following statement from one of them:- "I've
been all my life at coal portering, off and on, and am now 39. For the last two
years or so I've worked regularly as a filler to Mr. -- s waggons. I couldn't do
my work without a good allowance of beer. I can't afford so much now, as my
family costs me more, but my regular allowance one time was three pots a day. I
have drunk four pots, and always a glass of gin in the morning to keep out the
cold air from the water. If I got off then for 7s. a week for drink, I reckon'd
it a cheap week. I can't do my work without my beer, and no coal-porter can
properly. It's all nonsense talking about ginger beer, or tea, or milk, or that
sort of thing-what body is there in any of it? Many a time I might have been
choked with coal-dust if I hadn't had my beer to clear my throat with. I can't
say that I'm particular thirsty like next morning, after drinking three or four
pots of beer to my own work, but I don't get drunk." He frequently, and
with some emphasis. repeated the words, "but I don't get drunk."
"You see, when you're at such hard work as ours, one's tired soon, and a
drop of good beer puts new sap into a man. It oils his joints like. He can lift
better, and stir about brisker. I don't care much for beer when I'm quiet at
home on a Sunday. It sets me to sleep then. I once tried to go without to please
a master, and did work one day with only one half pint. I went home as tired as
a dog. I should have been soon good for nothing, if I'd gone on that way-half-pinting
in a day! Lord love you, we know a drop of good beer. The coal porters is
admitted to be as good judges of beer as any men in London; may be the best
judges, better than publicans. No salt and water will go down with us. It's no
use a publican trying to gammon us with any of his cag-mag stuff. Salt and water
for us! Sartainly a drop of 'short' (neat spirit) does one good in a cold
morning like this; it's uncommon raw by the waterside, you see. Coal-porter's
doesn't often catch cold; beer and gin keeps it out. Perhaps my beer and gin now
costs me 5s. a week, and that's a deal out of what I can earn. I dare say
I earn 18s. a week. sometimes I may spend 6s. That's a third of my earnings, you
say, and so it is; and as it's necessary for my work, isn't it a shame a poor
man's pot of beer, and drop of gin, and pipe of tobacco should be so dear? Taxes
makes them dear. I can read, sir, and I understand these things. Beer - four
pots a day of it - doesn't make me step unsteady. Hard work carries it off, and
so one doesn't feel it that way. Beer's made of corn as well as bread, and so it
stands to reason it's nourishing. Nothing'll persuade me it isn't. Let a
teetotal gentleman try his hand at coal work, and then he'll see if beer has no
support in it. Too much is bad, I know; but a man can always tell how much he
wants to help him on with his work. If beer didn't agree with me, why of course
I wouldn't drink it - but it does. Sartainly, we drops into a beer-shop of a
night, and does tipple a little, when work's done; and the old women (our wives)
comes for us, and they get a sup to soften them, and so they may get to like it
overmuch, as you say, and one's bit of a house may go to rack and manger. I've a
good wife myself, though. I know well enough all them things is bad -
drunkenness is bad; all I ask for is a proper allowance at work; the rest's no
good. I can't tell whether too much or no beer at coal work would be best -
perhaps none at all - leastways it would be safer. I shouldn't like to try
either. Perhaps coal porters does get old sooner than other trades, and mayn't
live so long, but that's their hard work, and it would be worse still without
beer. But I don't get drunk."
I conversed with several men on the subject of their
beer-drinking, but the foregoing is the only statement I met with where a
coal-porter could give any reason for his faith in the virtues of beer, and
vague as in some points it may be, the other reasons I had to listen to were
still vaguer. "Somehow, we can't do without beer; it puts in the strength
that the work takes out." "It's necessary for support." Such was
the pith of every argument.
In order fully to carry out this inquiry, I obtained the
address of a coal-backer from the ships, who worked hard and drank a good
deal of beer, and who had the character of being an industrious man. I saw him
in his own apartment, his wife being present while he made the following
statement:- "I've worked at backing since I was twenty-four, and that's
more than twelve years ago. I limit myself now, because times is not so good, to
two pots of beer a-day; that is, when I'm all day at work. Some takes more. I
reckon that when times was better, I drank fifteen pots a week, for I was in
regular work, and middling well off. That's 780 pots, or 195 gallons, a year,
you say. Like enough it may be - I never calculated, but it does seem a deal. It
can't be done without, and men themselves is the best judges of what suits their
work - I mean of how much to take. I'll tell you what it is, sir. Our work's
harder than people guess at, and one must rest sometimes. Now, if you sit down
to rest without something to refresh you, the rest does you harm instead of
good, for your joints seem to stiffen; but a good pull at a pot of beer backs up
the rest, and we start lightsomer. Our work's very hard. I've worked till my
head's ached like to split, and when I've got to bed, I've felt as if I had the
weight on my back still, and I've started awake when I fell off to sleep,
feeling as if something was crushing my back flat to my chest. I can't say that
I ever tried to do without beer altogether. If I was to think of such a thing,
my old woman there would think I was out of my head. [The wife assented.] I've
often done with a little when work's been slackish. First, you see, we bring the
coal up from the ship's hold. There sometimes it's dreadful hot, not a mouthful
of air, and the coal-dust sometimes as thick as a fog. You breathe it into you,
and your throat's like a flue, so that you must have something to drink. I fancy
nothing quenches you like beer. We want a drink that tastes. Then there's
the coals on your back to be carried up a nasty ladder, or some such
contrivance, perhaps 20 feet-and a sack full of coals weighs 2 cwt. and a stone
at least; the sack itself's heavy and thick. Isn't that a strain on a man? No
horse could stand it long. Then when you get fairly out of the ship you go along
planks to the waggon, and must look sharp, specially in slippery or wet weather,
or you'll topple over, and then there's the hospital or the workhouse for you.
Last week we carried along planks 60 feet at least. There's nothing extra
allowed for distance, but there ought to be. I've sweat to that degree in summer
that I've been tempted to jump into the Thames just to cool myself. The sweat's
run into my boots, and I've felt it running down me for hours as I had to trudge
along. It makes men bleed at the nose and mouth, this work does. Sometimes we
put a bit of coal in our mouths to prevent us biting our tongues. I do
sometimes, but its almost as bad as if you did bite your tongue; for when the
strain comes heavier and heavier on you, you keep scrunching the coal to bits,
and swallow some of it, and you're half choked, and then its no use, you must
have beer. Some's tried a bit of tobacco in their mouths, but that doesn't
answer; it makes you spit, and often spit blood. I know I can't do without beer.
I don't think they dulterate for us. They may for fine people that just tastes
it, and, I've heard has wine and things. But we must have it good, and a
publican knows who's good customers. Perhaps a bit of good grub might be as good
as beer to strengthen you at work, but the straining and sweating makes you
thirsty more than hungry, and if poor men must work so hard, and for so little,
for rich men, why, poor men will take what they feel will satisfy them, and run
the risk of its doing them good or harm, and that's just where it is. I can't
work three days running now without feeling it dreadful. I get a mate that's
fresher to finish my work. I'd rather earn less at a trade that would give a man
a chance of some ease; but all trades is overstocked. You see we have a nicish,
tidy room here, and a few middling sticks, so I can't be a drunkard."
I now give the statement of a coalporter who had been a
teetotaller:- "I have been twenty-two years a coalheaver.
When I began that work I earned 50s. a week as backer and filler. I am now
earning, one week with another, say 15s. We have no sick fund among us - no
society of any sort - no club - no schools - no nothing. We had a kind of union
among us before the great strike, more than fourteen years back, but it was just
for the strike. We struck against masters lowering the pay for a ton a man to
2¼d. from 2½d. The strike only lasted two or three weeks, and the men were
forced to give way; they didn't all give way at once, but came-to gradual. One
can't see one's wife and children without bread. There's very few teetotallers
among us, though there's not many of us now that can be called drunken; they
can't get it, sir. I was a teetotaller myself for two years, till I couldn't
keep to it any longer. We all break. It's a few years back, I forget zactly
when. At that time teetotallers might drink shrub, but that never did me
no good; a good cup of tea freshened me more. I used then to drink ginger-beer,
and spruce, and tea and coffee. I've paid as much as 5s. a week for ginger-beer.
When I teetotalled I always felt thirsty. I used to long for a drink of beer,
but somehow managed to get past a public-house until I could stand it no longer.
A clerk of ours broke first, and I followed him. I certainly felt weaker before
I went back to my beer. Now I drink a pint or two as I find I want it. I can't
do without it, so it's no use trying. I joined because I felt I was getting
racketty, and giving my mind to nothing but drink instead of looking to my
house. There may he a few teetotallers among us, but I think not. I only knew
two. We all break; we can't keep it. One of these broke, and the other kept it,
because if he breaks his wife'll break, and they were both regular drunkards. A
coal-porter's worn out before he's what you may call well old. There's not very
many old men among us. A man's done up at fifty, and seldom lives long after, if
he has to keep on at coal-portering. I wish we had some sick fund, or something
of that kind. If I was laid up now there would be nothing but the parish for me,
my wife, and four children." [Here the poor man spoke in a broken voice.]
"The masters often discharge old hands when they get feeble, and put on
boys. We have no coals allowed for our own firesides. Some masters, if we buys
of them, charges us full price; others, a little cheaper." I saw this man
in the evening, after he had left his work, in his own room. It was a large and
airy garret. His wife, who did not know previously of my visit, had in her
domestic arrangements manifested a desire common to the better-disposed of the
wives of the labourers or the poor - that of trying to make her "bit
of place" look comfortable. She had to tend a baby four months old; two
elder children were ill-clad, but clean; the eldest boy, who is fifteen, is in
the summer employed on a river steam-boat and is then of great help to his
parents. There were two beds in the room, and the bedding was decently arranged
so as to form a bundle, while its scantiness or worn condition was thus
concealed. The solitary table had a faded green cloth cover, very thread-bare,
but still a cover. There were a few cheap prints over the mantel-shelf, and the
best description I can give is, in a phrase not uncommon among the poor, that
the whole was an attempt "to appear decent." The woman spoke well of
her husband, who was kind to her, and fond of his home, and never drank on
Sundays.
Last of all I obtained an interview with two coal-porters who
had been teetotallers for some years.
"I have been a coal-porter ever since I have been able
to carry coals," said one. "I began at 16. I have been a backer all
the time. I have been a teetotaller eight years, on the 10th of next March. My
average earnings where I am now is about 35s. per week. At some wharfs work is
very bad, and the men don't average half that. They were paid every night where
I worked last, and sometimes I have gone home with 2½d. Take one with the other
I should say the coal-porter's earnings average about £1 per week. My present
place is about as good a berth as there is along the waterside. There is only
one gang of us, and we do as much work as two will do in many wharfs. Before I
was a teetotaller I principally drank ale. I judged that the more I gave for my
drink the better it was. Upon an average I used to drink from three to four
pints of ale per day. I used to drink a good drop of gin, too. The
coal-porters are very partial to dog's-nose - that is, half-a-pint of ale with a
pennyworth of gin in it, and when they have got the money, they go up to what
they term 'the lucky shop' for it. The coal- porters take this every morning
through the week, when they can afford it. After my work I used to drink more
than when I was at it. I used to sit as long as the house would let me have any.
Upon an average, I should say I used to take three or four pints more of an
evening; so that altogether I think I may fairly say I drank my four pots of ale
regularly every day, and about half-a-pint of' dog's-nose. I reckon my drink
used to cost me 13s. a week when I was in work. At times I was a drunken noisy
gentleman then." Another coal-porter, who has been a teetotaller ten years
on the 25th of last August, told me that before he took the pledge he used to
drink a great deal after he had done his work, but while he was at work he could
not stand it. "I don't think I used to drink above
three pints and a half and a pennyworth of gin in the daytime," said this
man. "Of an evening I used to stop at the public- house generally till I
was drunk, and unfit to work in the morning. I will vouch for it I used to take
about three pots a day after I had done work. My reckoning used to come to about
1s. 8d. a day, or, including Sundays, about 10s. 6d. per week. At that time I
could average all the year round about 30s. a week, and I used to drink away
10s. of it regularly; I did indeed, sir, more to my shame." The other
coal-porter told me his earnings averaged about the same, but he drank more.
"I should say I got rid of nearly one-half of my money. I did like
the beer then; I thought I could not live without it. It's between twelve and
thirteen years since the first coal-porter signed the pledge. His name was John
Sturge, and he was looked upon as a madman. I looked upon him myself in that
light. The next was Thomas Bailey, and he was my teetotal father. When I first
heard of a coal-porter doing without beer I thought it a thing onpossible. I
made sure they wouldn't live long. It was part of my education to believe they
couldn't. My grandfather brewed home-brewed beer, and he used to say to me,
'Drink, my lad, it'll make thee strong.' The coal-porters say, now if we could
get the genuine home-brewed, that would be the stuff to do us good - the
publicans' wash is no good. I drank beer then for strength. The stimulation
caused by the alcohol, I mistook for my own power." "Richard Hooper -
he's been a teetotaller now about twelve years. He was the fourth of the coaleys
as signed the pledge, and he first instilled teetotalism on my mind," said
the other man. "Where he works now, there's nine out of fifteen men is
teetotallers. Seeing that he could do his work much better than when he drinked
beer, induced me to become one. He was more regular to his work after he had
given it up, than whenever I knowed him before." "The way in which
Thomas Bailey put it into my head was this here," continued the other.
"He invited me to a meeting. I told him I would come, but he'd never make a
teetotaller of me, I knowed. I went with the intention to listen to what they
could have to say. It was a little bit curious to know how they could make out
that beer was no good for a body. The first man that addressed the meeting was a
tailor. I thought it might do very well for him; but then, says I, if you had
the weight of 238lbs. of coals on your back, my lad, you couldn't do it without
beer or ale. I thought this here because I was taught to believe I couldn't do
without it. I cared not what any man said about beer, I believed it was life
itself. After the tailor, a coal-porter got up to speak. Then I began to listen
more attentively. The man said he once had a happy home and a happy wife -
everything the heart could wish for, but through intoxicating drinks he had been
robbed of everything. The man pictured the drunkard's home so faithfully that
the arrows of conviction stuck fast in my heart, and my conscience said, 'thou
art a drunkard, too.' The coal-porter said his home had been made happy through
the principle of total abstinence. I was determined to try it from that hour. My
home was as miserable as it possibly could be, and I knowed intoxicating drink
was the cause on it. I signed the pledge that night, after the coal-porter was
done speaking, but was many months before I was thoroughly convinced I was doing
right in abstaining altogether. I kept thinking on it after going home of a
night, tired and fatigued with my hard work, sometimes scarcely able to get up
stairs through being so overwrought, and not being quite satisfied about it, I
took every opportunity to hear lectures on the subject. I heard one on the
properties of intoxicating drinks, which quite convinced me that I had been
labouring under a delusion. The gentleman analysed the beer in my presence, and
I saw that in a pint of it there was 14oz. of water - that I had been paying 2d.
for - 1oz. of alcohol - and 1oz. of what they call nutritious matter. but
which is the filthiest stuff man ever set eyes upon. It looked more like
cobbler's wax than anything. It was what the lecturer called-the residyum, I
think, was the name he gave it. The alcohol is what stimulates a man, and makes
him feel as if he could carry two sacks of coals while it lasts, but afterwards
comes the depression, that's what the coal-porters calls 'the blues,' and then
he feels that he can do no work at all, and he either goes home and puts another
man on in his place, or else he goes and works it off with more drink. You see
where we coal-porters have been mistaken, is believing alcohol was nutriment,
and in fancying that a stimulant was strength. Alcohol is nothing strengthening
to the body - indeed, it hardens the food in the stomach, and so hinders
digestion; you can see as much any day if you go into the hospitals, and look at
the different parts of animals preserved in spirits. The strength that alcohol
gives is unnatural and false. It's food only that can give real strength to the
frame. I have done more work since I've been a teetotaller in my eight years
than I did in ten or twelve years before. I have felt stronger. I don't say that
I do my work better; but this I will say, without any fear of successful
contradiction, that I do my work with more ease to myself, and with more
satisfaction to my employer, since I have given over intoxicating drinks. I
scarcely know what thirst is. Before I took the pledge I was always dry; and the
mere shadow of the pot-boy was quite sufficient to convince me I wanted
something. I certainly haven't felt weaker since I have left off malt liquor. I
have eaten more and drank less. I live as well now as any of the publicans do -
and who has a better right to do so than the man that works? I have backed as
many as sixty tons in a day since I took the pledge, and have done it without
any intoxicating drink with perfect ease to myself, and walked five miles to a
temperance meeting afterwards. But before I became a teetotaller, after the same
amount of work I should scarcely have been able to crawl home. I should have
been certain to have lost the next day's work at least; but now I can back that
quantity of coals week after week without losing a day. I've got a family of six
children under twelve years of age. My wife's a teetotaller, and has suckled
four children upon the principle of total abstinence. Teetotalism has made my
home quite happy, and what I get goes twice as far. Where I work now four of us
out of five are teetotallers. I am quite satisfied that the heaviest work that a
man can possibly do may be done without a drop of fermented liquor. I say so
from my own experience. All kind of intoxicating drinks is quite a delusion.
They are the cause of the working man's wages being lowered. Masters can get the
men who drink, at their own price. If it wasn't for the money spent in liquor,
we should have funds to fall back upon, and then we could stand out against any
reduction that the masters might want to put upon us, and could command a fair
day's wage for a fair day's work; but as it is, the men are all beggars, and
must take what the master offers them. The backing of coals out of the holds of
ships is man-killing work. It's scandalous that men should be allowed to force
their fellow-men to do such labour. The calves of a man's leg is as hard as a
bit of board after that there straining work. They hardly know how to turn out
of bed of a morning after they have been at that for a day. I never worked below
bridge, thank God, and hope I never shall. I have not wanted for a day's work
since I've been a teetotaller. Men can back out from a ship's hold better
without liquor than with it. We teetotallers can do the work better - that is,
with more ease to ourselves, than the drinkers can. Many teetotallers have
backed coals out of the hold, and I have heard them say over and over again that
they did their work with more comfort and ease than they did when they drank
intoxicating drink. Coal-backing from the ship's hold is the hardest work that
it is possible for a man to do. Going up a ladder sixteen feet high, with
238lbs. weight on a man's back, is sufficient to kill any one; indeed, it does
kill the men in a few years - they're soon old men at that work; and I do say
that the masters below bridge should be stopped going on as they're doing now.
And what for? Why, to put the money they save by it into their own pockets, for
the public a'n't no better off - the coals is just as dear there. Then the
whippers and the lightermen are all thrown out of work by it; and, what's more,
the lives of the backers are shortened many years - we reckon at least ten year.
"I wish to say this much," said the other teetotaller; "it's a
practice with some of the coal merchants to pay their men in public-houses, and
this is a chief cause of a great portion of the wages being spent in drink. I
once worked for a master upon Bankside as paid his men at a public-house, and I
worked a week there, which yarned me 28s. and some odd half-pence. When I went
on Saturday night the publican asked me what I was come for. In reply I said,
I'm come to settle. He says, 'You're already settled with' - meaning that I had
nothing to take. I had drinked all my lot away, he said, with the exception of 5s.
I had borrowed during the week. Then I told him to look back, and he'd find
I'd something due to me. He did so, and said there was a halfpenny. I had
nothing to take home to my wife and two children. I asked the publican to lend
me a few shillings, saying my young uns had nothing to eat. His reply was,
'That's nothing to me-that's your business.' After that I made it my business.
While I stood at the bar, in came the three teetotallers that worked along with
me, and picked up the 28s. each that was coming to them; and I thought how much
better they was off than me. The publican had stopped all my money for drink
that I knowed I'd not had; and yet I couldn't help myself, cause he had the
paying on me. Then something came over me as I stood there, and I said, from
this night, with the help of God, I'll never taste of another drop of
intoxicating liquors - that's ten years ago the 25th of last August - and I've
kept my pledge ever since, thank God. That publican has been the making of me.
The master that discharged me before for getting drunk, when he heard that I was
sober, sent for me back again. But before that, the three teetotallers who was
working along with me, was discharged by their master to oblige the publican
that stopped my money. The publican, you see, had his coals from the wharf. He
was a 'brass-plate coal merchant' as well as a publican, and had private
customers of his own. He threatened to take his work away from the wharf if the
three teetotallers wasn't discharged, and sure enough, the master did discharge
them rather than lose so good a customer. Many of the masters now are growing
favourable to teetotalism. I can say that I've done more on the principle of
total abstinence than ever I done before. I'm better in health. I've no
trembling when I goes to my work of a morning, but on the contrary I'm ready to
meet it. I'm happier at home. We never has no angry words now," said the
man with a shake of the head; and a strong emphasis on the now. "My
children never runs away from me as they used to before. They come and embrace
me more. My money now goes for eatables and clothes, what I and my children once
was deprived on through my intemperate habits, and I bless God and the publican
that made me a teetotaller - that I do sincerely - every night as I go to bed.
And as for men to hold out that they can't do their work without it, I'm
prepared to prove that we have done more work without it than ever we done, or
could do, with it."
I have been requested by the coalwhippers to publish the
following expression of gratitude on their part towards the Government for the
establishment of the Coalwhippers'-office: -
"The change that the Legislature has produced in us, by
putting an end to the thraldom of the publican, by the institution of this
office, we wish it to be generally known that we and our wives and children are
very thankful for."
I shall now conclude with the following estimate of the
number of the hands, ships, &c., engaged in the coal trade of London: -
There are about 400 wharfs, I am informed, from Wapping to Chelsea, as well as
those on the City Canal. A large wharf will keep about 30 horses, 6 waggons, and
4 carts, and it will employ constantly from 3 to 4 gangs of 5 men;
besides these there will be 6 waggoners, 1 cart carman, and about 2 trounsers -
in all from 24 to 29 men. A small wharf will employ one gang of 5 men,
about 10 horses, 3 waggons, and 1 cart; 3 waggoners, 1 trounser. and 1 cart
carman. At the time of the strike, sixteen years ago, there were more than 3,000
coal-porters, I am told, in London. It is supposed that there is upon an average
I gang and a-half, or about 7 men, employed in each wharf; or, in all, 2,800
coal-porters in constant employment, and about 200 odd men out of work.
There are, in the trade, about 4 waggons and 1 cart to each wharf, or 1,600
waggons, and 400 carts, having 5,200 horses; to these there would be
about 3 waggoners and 1 cart carman upon an average to each wharf, or 1,600 in
all. Each wharf would occupy about 2 trounsers, or 800 in the whole.
Hence the statistics of the coal trade will be as follows: -
Number of
Ships 2,177
Seamen 21,600
Tons of coal entering the port of London each year 3,418,340
Coal-meters 170
Coal-whippers 2,000
Coal-porters 3,000
Coal-factors 25
Coal-merchants 502
Coal-dealers 295
Coal-waggons 1,600
Horses for ditto 5,200
Waggoners 1,600
Trimmers 800