There is, as regards these habits, a
consensus of opinion which to my mind
carries conviction, that while there is more drinking there is less drunkenness
than formerly, and that the increase in drinking is to be laid mainly to the
account of the female sex. This latter phase seems to be one of the unexpected
results of the emancipation of woman. On the one hand she has become more
independent of man, industrially and financially, and on the other more of a
comrade than before, and in neither capacity does she feel any shame at entering
a public-house. As a rule, when men and women drink
together, the man stands treat, but women treat each other as much, and even
more than, is the case with men. Thus the social side of the consumption of
alcohol is emphasized, and to this may perhaps be ascribed very largely the
combination of more drinking with less drunkenness, of which almost everyone
speaks. Drunkenness, on the whole, is antisocial. “A really heavy drinker, one
who soaks for ten days or a fortnight, without eating any solids, does not sit
long over it as a rule, but goes home to come back when ready for more.” Women
are far more sociable in this matter. “One drunken woman in a street will set
all the women in it drinking. A woman is so often talking with her neighbours;
if she drinks they go with her.” Moreover, for men, “pony glasses” have
been invented to meet the case of “come
and have something,” when neither side wants to drink at all, and only does so
as a step in some business transaction. Among men who drink more shame is felt
than used to be the case at having been drunk. “Much more is drunk than
formerly,” says one witness, speaking of some of the rough Irish, “but there
is less drunkenness, partly because the beer is lighter, but more because of a
change in manners; nowadays you drink, and
the more you drink the better man you are, but you must not be visibly drunk.
Outward drunkenness is an offence against the manners of all classes.” The
ideal is to “carry your drink like a gentleman.” Of women it is however
said, that “they let the whole world know if they have had too much.”
Such is the position, looked at in a
very broad and general way, but there are diversities of opinion affected by the
point of view of the observer, as well as by the class observed, and once more I
offer my readers a patchwork of quotations. They are drawn from the police, from
the clergy, ministers of religion, and missionaries, from schoolmasters and
others. Drinking habits and the disorderliness
resulting from them could not but be continually mentioned in the course of the
long walks taken in all parts of London day after day with the picked police
officers who were permitted to assist us during the revision of our maps; and we
had the advantage of discussing these and other cognate subjects with their
divisional superiors. For the rest, I, of course, attach no names to the
opinions I quote, nor do I indicate the precise locality to which they bore
reference, but only when needed indicate the class.
As regards women: “Many
more women are seen in public- houses; the middle-aged are the drunkards, not
the young. Young people do their courting in public-houses, since both sides are
rather ashamed of their homes, and like to make themselves out a class above
what they are. The young men treat the girls to a glass of wine. No harm comes
of it. It is not till they get older that women take to gin and ale and become
regular soakers.” Again:
“Girls
begin when they first go out ‘keeping company’; neither sex become confirmed
soakers before twenty-five or thirty, or with women till after marriage. The
drunkards are probably married women.” Another police officer said: “Drunkenness
among women is on the increase,” but added that he had never seen a girl under
fifteen drunk, and that it was never common before marriage.
“They take too much at times, but are surprised at their own state. They do
not drink for drinking’s sake, and very little upsets them, especially on an
empty stomach. That is why so many are noisy on Saturday, when they are paid and
let out early, having had no lunch. They take a nip and become hilarious in no
time.” And another says: “Factory girls drink, but it is more often the
young married women and the middle-aged who indulge too much. Men drink beer;
women more often spirits. Women drink more than they used to, perhaps because
they earn more.”
“There
are various classes of women drinkers: the factory girl who drinks once in a
way, the prostitute who drinks in the course of business and very seldom gets
drunk, the laundry-woman who drinks by reason of the thirsty nature of her
trade, and the married woman who drinks because her husband drinks.” “‘Women
have lost all shame about entering a public-house, and as they never drink
singly, the evil spreads.” “Public-houses are more attractive than they
were; ladies’ saloon bars are to be seen everywhere.
Publicans tell you that it is in response to a demand, but it is difficult to
distinguish between cause and effect.” Such are other police opinions.
The clergy of the Church of England,
Nonconformist ministers, and schoolmasters may be
quoted to the same effect, though perhaps in some cases with more of a teetotal
bias, or with less sense of proportion. That “drinking has increased
enormously among women is heard again and again, and very rarely anything
to mitigate this opinion, only that it is added, “Young women do not get
drunk, unless on Bank Holidays or at marriages
or funerals.” “Drink worse than ever,” we are told, “especially amongst
women”; and this it is felt is “a funny thing in face of all the agencies.”
“Women drink to excess more than men. They take to it largely to carry them
through their work.” And again: “The women are worse than the men, but their
drinking is largely due to their slavery at the washtub.” Of the same class it
is said, “Nearly all get drunk on Monday. They say ‘we have our fling; we
like to have a little fuddle on Monday.’” And of a yet lower class we hear
that they “live on four-ale and fried fish.”
The
master of a poor school speaks of the habit of drinking among the women being
very general; “even quite respectable mothers, when they come to see him in
the morning, nearly always smell of drink.” Two other masters also mention the
large proportion of mothers who smell of beer when they come to see them at the
schools; while a schoolmistress, “judging from the women who come to see her,
infers that nearly all have a morning dram.” “The poorest and most destitute
seem,” she says, “to look upon drink as the first necessity of life.” A
Board school teacher at school in a poor neighbourhood says that the attendance
is worst early in the week, while the public-houses are full of women; “the
children being at home while the mothers drink.”
The
increase of the habit among women still applies as we pass slightly upwards in
the social scale. It is said to be “the regular thing for women to go in and
have a drink when shopping,” and another witness notices the “marked
increase in the number of respectably dressed young women who drink.” They may
be respectable as well as respectably dressed. One of the East End clergy told
how a woman who had been talking to him on the subject
said that “when she was young no one would have dreamt of going inside a
public-house. But things have altered. Her son is engaged, and the girl goes
with him there sometimes. In earlier years you would have put her down as not
respectable, but not so now.” A member of an Anglican Sisterhood put it that
“the time had long since gone by for regarding it as a scandal that a woman
should drink at the public-house.” And an “old resident,” speaking of the
increase of drinking among women, says: “You cannot but see it: respectable
women go into public-houses without any compunction, a sort of thing never seen
until late years.”
Amongst
the better-to-do, also, drinking is stated to be worse than it used to be, “especially
among women.~~ “Every doctor will tell you that women have acquired the habit
of ‘nipping.’ “ Some (said this witness) accuse grocers’ licences, but
he did not himself attach much importance
to them. The real reason was, he said, that the women had so little to do. “All
round London are growing up suburbs of small houses whose occupants have just
enough to live on comfortably. Women left at home; small ailments;
immediate stimulus of drink; that is how it begins.” Another agrees that “the
habit of drinking among women is most often contracted by young wives whose
husbands are away all day.” “Shop girls who marry find the loneliness in the
suburbs unbearable after shop life.” Emphasis is also laid by many on the
increasing amount of secret drinking among strictly middle-class women, and the
taking of morphia and other drugs, as a result, perhaps, of home troubles, and
medical men are blamed for not being careful enough when they prescribe
stimulants. But the most objectionable drinking is described as being found
among retired men of this class who have nothing to do and pass their time in
going from saloon bar to saloon bar. Thus do “City habits lead to disaster.”
... A parish nurse,
working in the East End, said that “as to drink, there is more there among
women than among men. They drink beer, or rather porter, not spirits, and always
in company. When once inside a public-house, they stay there. For this reason
she believed that if a law were passed (she was speaking in 1898) prohibiting
children from fetching the dinner and supper beer, it would do distinct harm to
East London.
... Another of the Church of
England clergy, speaking of women, said, “Worry is what they suffer from, rest
and hope what they want. Drunkenness dulls
the sense of present evil and gives a rosiness to what is to come. That is why
they drink.”
Charles Booth Life and Labour of the People in London, 1903